Only Baseball Matters

…. Misguided

In the face of so many calls for stricter penalties by so many misguided moralists in the mainstream media, Commissioner Selig has come out and said he is in favor of increasing the penalties for PED’s. This is, of course, absurd. The penalty system is fine. The testing system is as good as it needs to be:

…. In the year ending with the 2012 World Series, there were seven positives for performance-enhancing substances and 11 for stimulants among 3,955 urine tests and 1,181 blood tests, according to a report issued in November by baseball’s independent program administrator, Dr. Jeffrey M. Anderson.

So, .003% of all the tests come back positive, and the Commissioner, as well as the complete fools in the media are all in a tizzy about solving a “problem” that doesn’t exist. Again, the program works fine. But if you’re in the mood for a different take, David Pinto has a suggestion:

….I would suggest, however, that suspensions may not be the way to go. My recommendation would be to hit the players hard in the wallet. Every positive test moves the start of big money back two years, or does a reset to the minimum salary. So if a first year player gets caught, he has to wait five years instead of three for arbitration, then eight years instead of six for free agency. If he is already collecting an arbitration or free agent salary, the next two years are paid at the minimum. In other words, cheating takes away the salary guarantee. A player might take a chance for 50 games. He might not take a chance for millions of dollars.

It’s an interesting take, but again, the system works. Players are being harmed by the suspensions, teams are being harmed. Melky was essentially an outcast in SF after his suspension, banned from the postseason, and from an eventual championship. What more do you want? Shoot them? It’s a game, people. Someone cheats, they get suspended. Three strikes and you’re out. That’s enough. The Players Association should resist any further calls for tougher penalties. They have no incentive, and they are not required to.

UPDATE: Eric thinks the system isn’t working. Well, I think it is. I think we’re talking about something working versus a completely unrealistic goal of 100% eradication. We’re confusing “works” with “perfect.” No system will catch everyone, for the exact reasons you just stated, the incentives are too great. The idea isn’t to eliminate use to the point of 100% clean. That’ll never happen. To even come close to 100% would entail a level of personal invasiveness no player would thoughtfully agree to. That’s why we shouldn’t listen to the sportswriters, the players, or the owners, or cheap viagra even the commissioner when it comes to this issue. They aren’t experts. Far from it. They are consumers, they are sheep. When they say things like 11 positive tests out of almost 4000 vials of urine means the system isn’t working, it just illustrates how out of touch with reality they are.

There will always be a small percentage of people willing to do anything to achieve success. For the most part, those people are lauded as our heroes. The players agreed to this system. If some of them want to circumvent it, so be it. Some of them will get caught, and some won’t. That’s life. We could easily insure that every single person who ever speeds gets caught. Put GPS tracking devices in every car, and have it automatically issue a ticket pill marked cipro 500 every time you exceed the speed limit. Anybody want that? I could go on. How come it’s OK to ask Derek Jeter to allow someone to come to his house any hour of the day or night and ask him to pee in a cup? Because he plays a game? How is it so hard to see the absurdity in this situation?

The players have already given huge concessions in this situation. To give more baffles me.

If I were in the majors, I would never vote to allow that kind of intrusion in my life. But that’s me. I find it amazing that so many people would actively petition for the removal of another person’s privacy.

« Previous | Home | Next »

6 Responses to “…. Misguided”

  1. It very good what your said,38 boutiques en Chine, et a lancé une gamme complète de plate-forme de vente en ligne officielle, y compris le site UGG officielle chinoise.

  2. odthrcskkf says:

    Only Baseball Matters » Blog Archive » …. Misguided

  3. Incredible, entirely great. Therefore i’m just engaging in writing articles myself, almost nothing slightly close to your current producing prospective (ha! ) yet I”"d enjoy that you can consider my goods sometime!

  4. We use Storage Storage space 2003 along with 08 inside ESX5. VMware officially isn’t going to assist Hard drive Server 03 in ESX5, but it functions. we have not possessed virtually any performance problems so i have never dug all around inside the wood logs, though. organic meat possibly be experiencing plenty of mistakes and that i just don’t know concerning this. From the things i can see we are up and running fine. I carry out wish to mention that we all the actual subsequent: – Bring one particular more VMkernel per community card on the VMware coordinator. – Allocate only one System cards with each VMKernel. – Ensure that the modern VMKernels tend to be dynamic to the ISCSI HBA. – Set typically the multipath insurance plan on each of your ISCSI datastore to Circular Robin the boy wonder.

  5. My spouse and i hesitation you can find 12 people in this state who get voted to get Romney with the exception of the point that this individual hasn’t already released his or her tax returns. I am with Romney on this one particular.

  6. Today i want to never forget which Harry Reid is actually a other Mormon. d nBut you can find yet another thing the following this everyone is actually lacking Romney would possibly not forked out virtually any income tax for 10 years because he may not have received some cash to get several years. Hew very well could possibly have paid out him or her self a salary associated with $1 which can be completely 100 % legal and that is not really taxable, consequently not any “income” duty. (I still find it $7K actually need before you even have arranging, though it may be a touch fewer. ) n nHe may have rather used his funds as rewards that is beautifully legal (if it ought to be can also be a issue, but it *is* authorized, in addition to routinely done) and hence only got “investment” income on what they presumably paid for the appropriate income tax. Therefore someone that somehow (illegally) got a duplicate associated with Romney’s tax returns for the people decades simply sees your pet paying income taxes on expense pay with no realizing that it is in reality salary compensated while rewards in addition to knee-jerks the particular “didn’t fork out taxes” rule. some remarkable national insurance feel Microsoft. Goodman input it very best final summertime: Romney is incredibly REALLY prosperous. Very good she has adequate funds to not require éléments and payoffs so because of this might be trustworthy. And frankly, My spouse and i may treatment precisely how they usually spends *his* cash, I am much more concerned about how they (or NoBama) stays *OUR* income….

Leave a Reply

All commentary is the opinion of John J Perricone unless otherwise noted.
None of the opinions expressed should be construed as being endorsed by the
San Francisco Giants, Major League Baseball, or any other organization mentioned herein.

Powered by WordPress

eXTReMe Tracker

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons License