CRITICAL ACCLAIM
DETAILS
GIANTS LINKS
NATIONAL COVERAGE
SEARCH
LOGIN
ARCHIVES BY MONTH
…. More bad news

I know I tend to lean towards the negative. Sorry. As far as I can tell, the vast majority of what I read about the Giants is positive, and for a team that has had it’s share of worst in baseball players, contracts, offenses, and acts, that is simply Polly-Anna. The Giants are not one of the better run organizations in baseball, as suggested by this BP article:

…. the best-run teams of the decade:

1. Oakland Athletics Billy Beane (2000-09)
2. St. Louis Cardinals Walt Jocketty (2000-07), John Mozeliak (2008-09)
3. Cleveland Indians John Hart (2000-01), Mark Shapiro (2002-09)
4. San Francisco Giants Brian Sabean (2000-09)

Whatever. I don’t care how you measure it. The idea that any of the team’s success in the “aughts” was due to anyone but Bonds is provably false. They’re not one of the best-run teams, they are one of the worst. They are one of the worst.

I wrote several years ago that I thought Brian Sabean was riding on the coattails of the best offensive player of all-time, and that the minute Bonds was gone we’d all see just how bad Sabean was at building an offense. Well, we sure see now. The Giants have been one of the worst offenses in baseball from the instant Bonds left the team, and Sabean shows no signs at all of being able to turn things around. That he was rewarded with a contract extension after years of failing is astounding. That he is still around to throw money away, to trade away important and valuable prospects for more old, declining, injured and injury-prone mediocrities is frankly unbelievable. Sabean lives in a world where players are frozen in time, where the best thing a player gas ever done is what the player will do now, regardless of how long ago it was, or how fluky it was, or whether the player has undergone major surgery, or whether the player is injured.

…. Giants GM Brian Sabean was already pleased with his winter after re-signing second baseman Freddy Sanchez before he could reach the free-agent market, then signing free agents Aubrey Huff and Mark DeRosa to play first base and left field. However, Sabean is even happier after catcher Bengie Molina decided Friday to return to the Giants as a free agent on a one-year, $4.5 million contract on Friday following protracted negotiations with the Mets that did not produce the two-year deal he was seeking. The Giants did not want to commit to Molina beyond 2010 because of the presence of top catching prospect Buster Posey in their system.

…. Sabean thinks the Giants will contend after finishing 88-74 last year to end a streak of four consecutive losing seasons. Molina believes the Giants can do better than contend, commenting “I think we can get to the playoffs and win it all. This team is that good. The pieces are all here. We’ve just got to go out and do it.”

First off, the worry that someone would sign the broken-down, shadow of a former batting champion out from under the Giants is laughable. LAUGHABLE. Not only was Sanchez under contract for 2010, but there wasn’t a GM in the game who though as highly of him as Sabean did. Not one. There was absolutely no chance whatsoever that Sanchez was gonna play anywhere but major league baseball’s version of the Seniors Tour, San Francisco.

And as for this quote: “I think we can get to the playoffs and win it all” all I can say is, Huh?

That’s not optimism. That’s not even wishful thinking. That is blindness. The kind of blindness that cripples a team, the kind of blindness that allows one to trade away two of the team’s top four pitching prospects away at the deadline to acquire razor-thin, marginal talent upgrades. It is the kind of blindness that allows someone to sign one percent better players than the ones you have for another $4 or $6 million dollars; so that at the end of the day, they very amount of money needed to land a top free-agent has been wasted on five players who are not more than ten percent better than the five players you already had.

…. First Base: Aubrey Huff (.248 EqA, -1.0 WARP)

Given what we know about the defensive spectrum and the distribution of talent in baseball, it shouldn’t be too hard to find a player who can hit at a league-average clip and play first base in a manner that doesn’t suggest a future nomination for the Darwin Awards. Yet here we are. Huff had shaken off three years of mediocrity to enjoy something of a career year in 2008 (32 homers, .306 EqA), in part because he didn’t see all that much time in the field. With the departure of the undead Kevin Millar, the Orioles told Huff to reacquaint himself with the leather. Huff wasn’t egregiously awful afield (-2 FRAA), but his bat went limp (.253/.321/.405) before dying a miserable death upon being traded to Detroit, where he applied the coup de gràce to the Tigers’ season as a Replacement-Level Killer DH (.189/.265/.302).

That’s Aubrey Huff, our new first baseman. One of the worst hitters in baseball at his position, a player no better than either of the two first basemen we ended 2009 with, Travis Ishikawa or Ryan Garko –and arguably, worse– but as always, a player who is absolutely, positively, older. Once again, I cannot begin to understand how Sabean can fail –for virtually his entire career, now– to acquire a guy who can stand at first base, catch a throw from the shortstop, and hit a couple of home runs. In just the last two seasons, now, Sabean has spent $14 million dollars and traded one of our top young pitching prospects in his efforts to fill the easiest position to fill on the diamond. Who wants to bet Ishikawa is out there by the end of May? If he is, then you can know that the money and the prospect was wasted, COMPLETELY WASTED; because Brian Sabean cannot do his job.

And that’s just first base. I could go on and on. Shortstop? Please. Too easy. How about second base? Right now, the odds are just as good that Sanchez’s career is over as they are that he’ll be a key offensive contributor:

…. Sanchez has been hurting since the Giants obtained him from Pittsburgh in late July. He had said the Giants knew before the trade he’d need knee surgery to repair a torn meniscus (it was performed Sept. 30), and he went on the disabled list Aug. 25 with a strained shoulder, the same shoulder that was surgically fixed last month.

The surgery repaired a torn labrum and cleaned up an arthritic AC joint, said Groeschner, who added that recovery could take 12 to 15 weeks.

Asked why the shoulder damage was not detected in the physical and MRI exam before the contract was consummated, Groeschner said, “Sports medicine is not black and white all the time. It’s not just reading an MRI. A lot of interpretation goes into it.”

Asked if he would have done anything differently with the contract in retrospect, general manager Brian Sabean said, “Not at all. Due diligence was done on the medical side. This is something we couldn’t pinpoint. It shows the medical profession isn’t perfect. … There’s nothing more we could have done. We checked out every medical question.”

That is disingenous at best. Everyone knew Sanchez was injured. Everyone. For Sabean to sit here and say they did due diligence is, at best, an admission of failure. At worst, it is a bold-faced lie. This is the exact same thing that happened when Sabean went out and signed Edgardo Alfonzo. The. Exact. Same. Thing:

…. (December 16, 2003)

Manager Felipe Alou said Alfonzo, 29, could hit third or fifth. While he batted .308 for the Mets last season, 10th in the National League, Alfonzo had 16 home runs and 56 RBIs, his second straight subpar season on the power front.

In 1999 and 2000, he averaged 26 homers and 101 RBIs. A back injury hurt his numbers in 2001 (.243, 17 homers, 49 RBIs), and it was speculated in New York that he also suffered the consequences in 2002 even though he was considered healthy.

The Giants were so confident that Alfonzo has recovered that they didn’t require him to take a physical.

“It feels pretty good. I’m fine,” Alfonzo said. “Last year, I dedicated the offseason to working out and getting in great condition.

The Giants were so confident that Alfonzo has recovered that they didn’t require him to take a physical.

That was six-plus years ago. What’s changed? Only the cast of nobodies Sabean goes out and wastes money on. They’re still old, injured, and declining. The team still says it cannot afford top-flight hitters. Still says nobody wants to come here (except, of course, the really old guys who see the Giants as the Seniors Tour of baseball).

So, sorry, I cannot focus on the positive. Sure, our pitching is tremendous. I love seeing Lincecum dominate. I am ecstatic about how good and young our core of arms are.

But the way Brian Sabean treats this essentially unprecedented bounty is unforgivable. And this team will tease us, because the pitching will be so dominant at times. And then Brian Sabean will trade away some more good, young pitching to acquire some old, broken down baseball player who is five percent better than the old, broken down player we are already paying, and our future will continue to recede into the dark.


« Previous | Home | Next »

76 Responses to “…. More bad news”

  1. Testing And Tracking nfl jersey In Order To Rock The nfl jersey Scene
    designer michael kors logo print large purple satchels we predict unlimited values http://www.april-six.com/michael-kors-large-fulton-crossbody/wxieaosc-p-312.html

  2. Caution – Don’t Attempt to go by other nfl jersey Guides Until You Read Through This Totally free Documentation
    cheap gucci garment bag with signature web loop 246385 f567n 1060 gucci handbags outlet at our professional online store http://www.lasvelasmarinaclub.com/gucci-hobo-handbag/gucci-garment-bag-with-signature-web-loop-246385-f567n-1060—gucci-handbags-outlet-p-1632.html

  3. Units and end production throughout Sin City — nfl jersey has left without any bon voyage
    canada michael kors gia metallic crocodile embossed leather tote golden take a walk down our aisles and save http://www.ambassadorprotocol.com/purses-michael-kors/michael-kors-gia-metallic-crocodile-embossed-leather-tote-golden-p-3967.html

  4. To Prospects Who Wants To understand nfl jersey But Fail to Move On
    cheap new style gucci handbags snaffle bit small shoulder bag with hand stitching 263956 ang0g 4305 coupon code http://www.windraver.net/gucci-france/gucci-handbags-snaffle-bit-small-shoulder-bag-with-hand-stitching-263956-ang0g-4305-p-937.html

  5. Who else should you follow? nfl jersey supporters regarding Twitter
    fashion womens lacoste white purple casual shoes outlet york http://www.pdpcrafts.com/how-to-spot-a-fake-lacoste-polo/womens-lacoste-white-purple-casual-shoes-p-8955.html

  6. Unique blog post supplies the basic truth over nfl jersey which just a couple of buyers know.
    professional gucci handbags briefcase 201480 aiz1g 2044 fill you cart with savings http://www.caddyforthecure.com/gucci-flora-perfume/gucci-handbags-briefcase-201480-aiz1g-2044-p-6336.html

  7. Actual Tips On How To Learn nfl jersey And Ways In Which One Could Link up with The nfl jersey Elite
    buy authentic gucci 2012 sneakers in canvas in white g525 2014 sale outlet http://www.sayangnaricards.com/gucci-factory-outlets/gucci-2012-sneakers-in-canvas-in-white-g525-p-3833.html

  8. nfl jersey Counterfeits — A Superb nfl jersey ‘cheat’ Which usually Fools 91% of the shoppers
    best cheap mens lacoste camden retro black white shoes fast shipping http://www.mesaskies.com/lacoste-dress-shirts/mens-lacoste-camden-retro-black-white-shoes-p-2208.html

  9. Items and production in The state of washington – nfl jersey actually leaves with no good-bye
    best quality gucci outlet watches i gucci collection extra large version 237944 i16q0 1065 store online http://www.mn.com.do/gucci-outlet-online-sale/gucci-outlet—watches-i-gucci-collection-extra-large-version-237944-i16q0-1065-p-1594.html

  10. Components and performance throughout Miami – nfl jersey will leave without any see you later
    the latest gucci 2012 loafers in leather in black g638 free shipping http://www.luminaireltd.com/authentic-gucci-sneakers/gucci-2012-loafers-in-leather-in-black-g638-p-9567.html

  11. The Most Comprehensive nfl jersey Strategy guide You Ever Witnessed Otherwise Your Money Back
    buy authentic gucci handbags sukey medium hobo with detachable interlocking g charm 232955 fafxg 9643 soaking up summer fun http://www.agorabotswana.com/gucci-at-saks/gucci-handbags-sukey-medium-hobo-with-detachable-interlocking-g-charm-232955-fafxg-9643-p-3662.html

  12. Probably The Most Comprehensive nfl jersey Manual You Ever Read Or Your Money Back

  13. Get a nfl jersey With no need of Paying A Single Nickle

  14. – * Abercrombie & Fitch Polo Shirt WHITE Size – MEDIUM Abercrombie Outlet * Very good,prompt delivery,great item Abercrombie US * Abercrombie Sale Very Fast delivery,Fab t-shirt,Will defo use this seller.again A*****. Arrived very quickly. Happy with everything.

Leave a Reply

SPONSORS
FANTASY BASEBALL
STEROIDS & BASEBALL
MORE BASEBALL
SEARCH BY CATEGORY
MORE SPORTS
  
All commentary is the opinion of John J Perricone unless otherwise noted.
None of the opinions expressed should be construed as being endorsed by the
San Francisco Giants, Major League Baseball, or any other organization mentioned herein.

Powered by WordPress

eXTReMe Tracker
  



Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a
Creative Commons License